The ingredients were the same but from different companies.
The product smelled a bit less like what I thought was the geranium. Can I add more geranium to the face serum? I tried to add a bit more of the essential oil but it did not change the scent (which I loved from the first batch). I think it was mainly the scent that was different.
Also the vitamin e from our local wholesaler was slightly colored (and the one from the local health food store was not).